Thread:Hasherstar98/@comment-24053170-20200425063113/@comment-24053170-20200426082954

The twitter page is based on Authors notes. Which is considered a valid source.

I mentioned that above that authors notes are valid.

Look, I'm not trying to restrict edits. i'm simply trying to have absolute concrete evidence and proof to back it up.

A lot of users post things they claim are valid when they actually aren't.

I never said anything about the Machikado Mazoku wiki. And I am not sure why your even bothering to bring it up in this conversation.

Official artbooks have actual measurement charts that are used for the series in questions.

The drawings for this wikia series are definitely not reference material. And in fact they look like a child's attempt at drawing the characters faces-

https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/shobitch/images/d/d5/Male.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20200424214655

https://vignette.wikia.nocookie.net/shobitch/images/6/61/Female.jpg/revision/latest?cb=20200424214646

Do you honestly believe any company would accept that as reference material? Even as a joke that's really taking it to far. Those two pictures are clearly pieces of fanart or just doodles.

I can respect your claims for the rest of the images you provided (netoge and sunohara), but those two pictures above are not drawn by the staff.

As for Netoge, I can agree that those last two links are based on the anime.

The reason I have a hard time believing your sources is because most series never publish any measurement charts for their official characters, instead there actually pieces of fanart that they claim are made by the companies.

Unless the chart is published in an artbook, its impossible to tell for certain that its actually made by the company responsible for creating the series.

That Demon Girl Next Door size chart is official, and I am not disagreeing with that.

Artbooks are (and remain) the most accurate source for official designs, references, concept art, model sheets and character sizes. Because they have been complied and published by the company that made the series.

I'm not trying to restrict your edits. If the edits come from a confirmed official source related to the series then I have no complaints and won't touch the edits.

Its just when I see edits that don't have a credible source that I undo them.

if you can list authors or staff notes as being involved in the source, then I won't touch them.

All in all, I can respect your beliefs and your desire to post what you believe is right.